Sporto vs Hunter Duck Shoes Womens Which Keeps Feet Drier

Man, what a rainy mess this week. Got sick of wet feet walking the dog, so I grabbed two pairs claiming to be waterproof ladies’ boots everyone talks about: the Hunter originals and those Sporto duck boots. Here’s exactly what I did to see which truly kept my toes dry.

Getting Ready for the Downpour

First up, gotta set the scene right? I waited for a legit rainy day – none of that drizzly nonsense. We’re talking steady, soaking rain all morning. Pulled out both boots. The Hunters felt sleek, kinda stiff. The Sportos? Way chunkier right out the box, like proper rubber rain boots should feel. Put on regular cotton socks for both tests – kept it real.

Testing Round One: The Deep Puddle Jump

Okay, initial torture test. Found this giant nasty puddle near the curb, like ankle-deep water. Totally gross. Pulled on the Hunter boots first. Felt fine walking normally… but then? Just went for it. Stomped HARD into that puddle, held my foot down for a good 10 seconds. Pulled it out… soaked sock! Water came gushing OVER the top edge straight into the boot. Ugh. Tried again being super careful, tiny steps. Stayed dry. So, lesson? Wading? Forget it with these. They’re more about style than deep water.

Dried my foot, switched to Sportos. Same aggressive stomp into the murk. Held it deep. Water splashed up the sides but… the higher cut actually worked! Nothing came over the top. Nice. Shook my leg around a bit – felt solid. Finally pulled it out. Sock? Bone dry, just like that. Big surprise. So Sportos clearly handled the deep stuff better.

Testing Round Two: The Long Wet Grass Slog

Okay, puddles are one thing. What about walking forever in soaking wet grass? That’s real life. Took each pair for a separate 30-minute dog walk across the totally soaked park lawn. Think swampy, squishy mess everywhere.

Started with Sportos again. Clunky, yeah. Not super light. But the traction? Brilliant. Didn’t slip once. Walked through inches of soggy thatch, stepped in hidden puddles… kept going. Got home, pulled them off. Socks? Perfectly dry. Boot interior felt slightly damp, like trapped sweat maybe? But my actual socks showed zero water stains. Good stuff.

Next day, same soaking grass route in the Hunters. They feel lighter, sleeker walking. Less bulky. But 10 minutes in, I noticed it – that familiar cold squish near my toes. Oh no. Kept walking, hoping it was just sweat. Nope. Got home, dumped the water out. My sock toes were soggy! Checked the boot liner – definite leak along the side stitching. So much for “waterproof.” Plus, got almost zero traction on a muddy slope. Long wet walks? Sportos won hands down.

My Brutal Honest Takeaway

Here’s the straight talk based on wrecking my feet for science:

• Hunter Originals: Look great. Feel kinda nice. But that low cut? Water magnet over the top if you’re not tip-toeing. And mine leaked like a sieve through the stitching after minimal use. Totally ruined it for me. Good for light showers and Instagram pics ONLY.
• Sporto Duck Boots: Heavy? Yup. Stylish? Depends who you ask. But dang, they WORKED. Kept me completely dry stomping through ankle-deep crap and long soggy walks. That higher cut mattered. The chunky soles felt glued to the mud. Actual waterproofing held up under real pressure. Worth the weight if dry feet are your jam.

Look, if you want dry feet in actual wet weather? It’s not even close for me. The Sportos slaughtered the Hunters plain and simple. Hunters might look cuter on the shelf, but they folded hard in the real world. Don’t waste your cash on soggy socks. Get the Sportos for actual rain, end of story.